Food for Thought

Food for Thought

As dissertation Chairs, when we read a student's proposal, how often do we sit back and ask " How can I help this person shed their biases?"   The answer is, they can't unless they become aware of them.  What strategies do you use to help your students become aware of their biases?  It is relatively easy to identify biases in the writings of others be it a student or a colleague.  Yet what do we do to help ourselves uncover our own biases that often unbeknownst to us appear ever so subtlly stated in our own writing?  

Comments

Margaret Vianna's picture Margaret Vianna | April 18, 2017 7:02 pm MST

You have presented a question that has no easy answer:  "How can I help this person shed biases?"

Learning to write without biases for students and professors begins with self-awareness.  As we read and interpret data, we bring our experiences with us into the learning process.  What is important is to understand that as we read and conduct research, we must have an awareness of our biases so that we may read and interpret despite personal biases and experiences.  Self-awareness and exploration of beliefs would be a solid place to begin as students read and begin interpretation of research.  I believe professors can assist students in examining beliefs through a series of questions regarding upbringing, family values, and other cultural beliefs that may play a role in research.  Sometimes students are busy looking forward.  Looking inward may assist students in understanding biases and the role biases play in research and data interpretation.  What do you think about self-awareness? 

Elizabeth Young's picture Elizabeth Young | April 18, 2017 7:12 pm MST

Margaret, you are making a great point about how often students forge ahead in an anxious attempt to begin writing their dissertation proposals.  When they do not begin with a slate of self-awareness of who they are, they simply waste a lot of time treading water.  Thank you for your insightful response.  Liz 

Margaret Vianna's picture Margaret Vianna | April 23, 2017 3:05 am MST

Liz, thank you for your response.  What are your thoughts on how to assist students to interpret their study data without biases?  From writing the research instrument to interview techniques, students must be cautious while they interpret data.   Member checking during interpretation of participants' responses may assist student researchers in reducing biases.  What do you think about CQR (Consensual Qualitative Research) methodology, wherein multiple researchers interpret the data and discuss the emerging themes to come to a consensus?  Do you believe this would help researchers increase their self-awareness and address biases during data interpretation in qualitative research?  What are your thoughts on coming to a group consensus on emerging themes? 

About the Author

Elizabeth Young

Additional content will be provided upon request.

Elizabeth Young
More posts by author:

Visit Our Blog

Visit the Research Process Blog for insights and guidance from University researchers Go >>


 

Recent News